Human Rights Defenders Assess Risks of Restoring Military Courts in Ukraine
The «Pryncyp» human rights center analyzed initiatives to establish military justice and explained why civilian judges are better equipped to protect the rights of service members.
🎓EducationPhoto: Ukrainska Pravda
Key points
- Human rights defenders analyzed initiatives regarding military justice
- Creation of military courts poses risks to judicial independence
- Specialization of existing civilian judges serves as an alternative
Discussions regarding the reinstatement of military courts and prosecutor's offices in Ukraine have intensified amid the full-scale war. A Temporary Special Commission of Parliament is currently reviewing relevant legislative initiatives while involving specialized civic organizations in the discussions. The primary argument raised by proponents of such changes is that only individuals with direct military experience can fully understand the specifics of army life.
Arguments Concerning Independence and Vertical Risks
However, experts from the «Pryncyp» human rights center for service members warn against hasty steps. In their view, integrating judges into the military vertical creates a threat to their independence, as the assignment of ranks and disciplinary subordination through the Ministry of Defense or the General Staff pave the way for external pressure. Participants in these discussions have previously encountered initiatives aimed at tightening subordination rules without simultaneously balancing norms regarding command abuses.
Over years of large-scale confrontation, the civilian judicial system has accumulated significant practical experience in handling such cases. Furthermore, most regulatory acts governing military service are adopted by civilian institutions. When deep expertise is required, courts can engage specialized professionals, whereas military status alone does not automatically guarantee flawless knowledge of legislation.
Solutions and Alternative Specialization
Instead of completely restructuring the system and establishing separate courts, experts propose implementing a narrow specialization among existing civilian judges. This approach would improve the quality of handling offenses against the established order of military service without risking the loss of judicial independence. Additionally, the practical implementation of creating separate military courts today would face significant personnel and organizational challenges.
Source Ukrainska Pravda — pravda.com.ua/news/2026/11/20/8063800/ ↗
Read next
🚨EventsMan shot dead in Kharkiv: police launch manhunt
A shooting incident in Kharkiv on the evening of November 22 resulted in one fatality. Police have launched a special operation to locate the suspects.
Rescue operation in Kyiv region: 7-year-old boy pulled from rubble after 14 hours
In the town of Dymer, rescue teams saved a child who spent nearly 14 hours under the debris of a residential building following a drone attack.
🚌TransportTrolleybus depot destroyed and metro suspended in Dnipro following enemy shelling
A Sunday evening attack on Dnipro caused significant damage to city infrastructure, including an electric transport depot and energy networks.
How to Protect Homes in Chernihiv from Rodents Before Winter Freezes
As cold weather arrives in Chernihiv, rodents seek shelter and food in basements, garages, and residential buildings.
Death toll rises in Dymer following Russian drone attack in Kyiv region
President Volodymyr Zelensky reported an increase in the number of casualties following a Russian drone strike on a residential building in Dymer.
Miracle in Dymer: 7-Year-Old Boy Rescued After 14 Hours Under Rubble
In the village of Dymer, Kyiv region, rescuers pulled 7-year-old Davyd alive from the ruins of a five-story building destroyed by a Russian drone strike.